What Is A Slogan Maker And Does It Actually Work?

Slogan Maker Does A Slogan Maker Actually Work?

As an organization that is passionate about slogans, we were astonished to see how many people search the Internet for the term “slogan maker.”  We've heard of bread makers.  We've heard of the candlestick maker in nursery rhymes.  We've even heard of a boxing punch known as a Hey-maker.  But what exactly is a slogan maker?

We got to thinking.  Maybe people search the term slogan maker because they have little idea on the best route to get a slogan made.

If you really wanted to define the ways catchphrases, taglines and catchy slogans are generated, then we guess you could say there are four kinds of slogan makers out there.  Or stated a little more accurately, there are four different ways one could go about getting an effective slogan or tagline.  We're about to list them all in order from what we feel is the worst way to go about getting a tagline or slogan to the best “slogan maker” option we think is out there.

The Automated Website

This is basically an online app that works as a slogan generator in that it uses an algorithm to put keywords together in the hopes of generating a slogan.  Usually a free service that makes money from advertising, your chance of getting a good slogan or tagline is probably about the same as your chance of winning the lottery.  For example a site like the sloganizer will randomly insert words like “quality” and phrases like “you'll love this.”  So you do end up with a short group of words but will it be remembered by anyone?  Probably not.  Well maybe people would remember it by thinking, “Remember that awful slogan that sounded like it was generated by a computer program”? Your slogan is a direct reflection on you and your business so if nothing else, make sure it's not “written” by a sloganizer, automated program or any other entity lacking an actual brain. 

 

The Solo Writer

This is a slogan maker that is in some ways not dissimilar to the candlestick maker in that it's one person, usually a solo freelance writer, who will be making slogans and taglines for clients.

While you might get some decent options, going with one person to solve your problem is risky.  First, you're putting your eggs all in one basket.  Unlike even the sloganizer automated website, freelancers get sick, they have writers block, they decide to take a job at that agency that finally has an opening.  Lots of things can happen that can leave you in the lurch.  Plus you're just getting the perspective of a single writer.  There is a cost involved that can range of the reasonable to the outrageous.  Generally you could expect to be charged anywhere from $800 - $2000 depending on the writers skill, experience, reputation and demand.  Often those rates pale in comparison to your next option, the marketing agency.

The Advertising Agency

You don't have to worry about the risk factor involved with hiring a freelance slogan writer. Advertising slogans are often created by a team of writers, each with a different perspective.  Plus, unlike a freelance slogan writer, there's not much of a chance an entire agency is going to decide to take three months off to backpack Europe in the middle of an assignment.  Advertising agencies usually have very good talent as well, meaning you'll hopefully get good work and multiple options.  The problem with this slogan maker service is in price and turnaround time.  Obviously, reserving the time of multiple slogan makers can lead to a pretty substantial bill.  Also, because many ad firms book projects out weeks in advance and are often taking on more work than they can actually handle, it's often 4-6 weeks before you would see any work.  If you can wait that long, fine, but many people want to start putting a slogan into action immediately so it's not an ideal situation. 

 

An Effective Alternative – Slogan Crowdsourcing

Crowdsourcing slogans are a fairly recent phenomenon.  Often called the ultimate slogan generator, this process involves creating slogans by starting a slogan contest. Slogan Slingers is the leader in this particular category.  Here's how it works.  First you would describe your needs – just like you would do to an ad agency or solo writer.  Then you determine the price….Yes, you determine the price. You can set a contest prize usually for as little as $50 to near $1000 (even the upper range can be less than a freelance slogan writer or ad agency's minimum charge). Then an alert goes out to writers who have registered with the site.  This can include moonlighting ad agency writers, freelancers and even talented amateurs.  Some contests see well over 100 submissions encompassing a lot of different styles and approaches.  The prize money goes to the writer who has submitted the slogan you love the best.  Even better, the turnaround is 7 days and you can pick a winner even before then if you feel the perfect line has been submitted.

No matter which route you choose, just about every marketing expert would tell you that a slogan can really make an impact on your organization.  So whether you need a restaurant slogan, law firm slogan, accounting slogan or anything else, take action.  Find a slogan maker approach that works for you.  You'll be glad you did!